Chest pack or backpack

[wee bri]

I normally use conventional fishing bags but for going to some of the hill lochs with the minimum amount of gear, I was thinking I might get myself one of those Scierra chest packs. I like the idea that even while you wear it everything is to hand....especially the hip flask.
However I was also wondering whether, with that bulk at the front, if they interfere with your casting.
Anybody tried one of these.
Would I be better just buying a small backpack instead..........wee bri...........

[superscot]

Bri
I prefer the rucksack let you haul all yer gear in some comfort! Also makes you take more than you will ever need ?always the same ? as bandy says once base camp is set up have a smaller bag for carrying the essential gear about 

[Malcolm]

bri,

Chestpacks are awful for walking in, in my not very humble view. Waistpacks are only slightly better. They may be all right for walking out of your car onto a river but for combining hills and fishing you need a rucksack. 25 or 30 litres is ideal for a day. Things that are useful are - look for one that has a crampon (or snow shovel) pocket - ideal for flasks! some have walking pole holders and these can be used for multipiece rods - but check out that your own rods fit. 
Lastly make sure it has a hydration pocket - a godsend!
Malcolm

[Malcolm]

Bri,

I should have said earlier that I actually use an Orvis chestpack for river fishing when I don't have to walk too far (and carry too much). For this purpose I think it is better than a conventional small fishing bag.

Malcolm

[Traditionalist]

I normally use conventional fishing bags but for going to some of the hill lochs with the minimum amount of gear, I was thinking I might get myself one of those Scierra chest packs. I like the idea that even while you wear it everything is to hand....especially the hip flask.
However I was also wondering whether, with that bulk at the front, if they interfere with your casting.
Anybody tried one of these.
Would I be better just buying a small backpack instead..........wee bri...........

I use a chest pack a lot. Much more convenient than a back-pack,  which one also often tends to take off and leave on the bank. Cost me several large boxes of flies and some other stuff doing that!

I have used several. If you want really top class stuff, have a look at webbing packs at an army and navy "surplus" store. Various pouches and a "tactical" or "assault" vest can be customised to suit perfectly, and one gets very high quality, usually for a very good price;

http://www.transworldsurplus.co.uk/webbing_assault_vests.asp

Have a look at the "web Tex" assault vest, and the "web-tex" chest rig shown above ( scroll down to find).

http://www.surplusandadventure.com/ishop/800/shopscr3291.html

These things normally cost a very great deal more money elsewhere.

I still use an old "army type" Goretex jacket for "normal" fishing. Have been using it for over thirty years now. I could live for a month just on the pocket contents!

Camouflage stuff has always been a favourite of mine, and I think it gives you an advantage in many circumstances. ( When fishing as well!   )

TL
MC